
On the morning of the following Sunday, The Old Man woke early. So early, in fact, that the sun had not yet risen. After toasting a couple of Eggos, he somehow got it into his head to go on a walk to his old high school, which was only two miles away from his house. He squeezed on his sneakers and headed out.
When the Old Man had walked about three-quarters of a mile, he found himself on top of a grassy hill. He stopped and turned East. The sun popped into view like a light-up blood orange, spewing its juices all over New England, and the Old Man walked down the other side of the hill.
"What am I doing?" he asked himself. "Why am I here?"
When he was only a block away from his old high school, the Old Man noticed a shiny nickel laying on the sidewalk. He picked it up and examined it.
"Why," he said to himself "This nickel is quite unlike any nickel I have seen before. It differs in some essential quality, but I cannot seem to put my finger on which quality makes this nickel unique. Perhaps the lettering is bigger. Was the building on the back always so lumpy? It seems to be somehow lacking in detail, like it is not a nickel but a mockery of a nickel. Someone must have made it in order to poke fun at people who rely on money to save them-- as if it were Jesus or the South Beach Diet-- from solitude, decrepitude, irrelevance, and self-examination but never look at their money closely enough to recognize a parody. How clever I am not to have fallen for for the trick!"
The old man put the fake quarter in his pocket and continued walking toward his old high school in a cloud of self-satisfied humming, but when he reached the lawn in front of the school, he still did not know exactly how his fake quarter was different from a real quarter. This thought nagged at him so persistently that he determined he must find a real quarter to compare with his. He walked across the street to the house of a stranger and knocked on the front door. A young man came to the door and looked inquiringly out at him from a fat face.
"May I have a nickel?" asked the old man. "I need to make a phone call."
"It costs fifty cents to use the pay phone now, old man," said the young man.
"I already have forty-five cents," replied the Old Man. The young man clinked his fat hand around in a bowl next to the door and then handed the Old Man a nickel.
"Thank you," said the old man, and he walked back to the lawn in front of the school where he sat down to compare. He took the fake nickel out of his pocket and held it up next to the new nickel. They both had their faces towards him, and he stared and stared, but there was no difference. He turned them around, but they looked exactly the same on both sides. And suddenly he knew something he had not known before.
It was not the nickel that was different but himself. Something in his brain. He was looking at the nickel differently or thinking about it differently, and worse, he realized that this was not the first time. Looking back on the week, he remembered many things which had seemed to him changed in some small way. His toothbrush, his mailbox, the pillow from the couch which he always used to like holding on his lap when he sat down and there was no company, and now nickels. They had all changed for him, but he did not know how they had changed, because he could not remember the way they used to be.
"The subconscious knowledge of this bizarre metamorphosis must have been the source of my impulse to visit my old high school," he told himself. "I'll go inside and look at the things I used to see every day. I'll touch the walls and smell the air. I can't remember how things were before last week, but maybe I'll be able to remember what they were like fifty-five years ago. I will figure out how it all was and be very careful not to forget this time." The old man put the two nickels back in his pocket and walked up to the front door of his old high school. He pulled on the handle, but the door did not move. "It must be locked," said the old man to himself. "I forgot it was Sunday."